Hospitality Property Fund share swap takes flak

Posted On Sunday, 13 December 2015 14:05 Published by
Rate this item
(0 votes)

Two minority shareholders urge Hospitality Property Fund to sweeten the share swap deal that forms part of its turnaround strategy, saying its failure to do so could jeopardise the company’s future.


Two minority shareholders have urged Hospitality Property Fund to sweeten the share swap deal that forms part of its turnaround strategy, saying its failure to do so could jeopardise the company’s future.

Grindrod Asset Management chief investment officer Ian Anderson and Steyn into one B unit structure as part of the turnaround strategy.

The dual unit structure was originally developed to offer different risks and rewards for shareholders. Investors who own the less risky A units are paid distributions first, which are capped at consumer price index or 5%, whichever is lower.

The B unitholders receive the balance and have the potential to reap both greater rewards and losses. However, Hospitality has been such a poor performer that the B unitholders have received relatively little income over the years. This together with the costs of managing two listings that share assets has led to the decision to discard the dual structure. Under the existing share swap deal, A unit holders will receive 3.5 B units in Hospitality for each A unit.

Part of the Hospitality restructuring also involves gaming and leisure group Tsogo Sun taking over the real estate investment trust which has performed poorly post the 2010 Soccer World Cup. Tsogo Sun owns a large portion of the B units. It plans to inject 10 hotels into Hospitality, raising the group’s asset base from R5bn to R15bn.

“Grindrod and Steyn cannot vote given such relatively small holdings but we can bring the issue to the public’s attention. The firm has been through a difficult time and if the A unitholders decline the share swap agreement and it collapses, the whole company’s future could be in jeopardy,” said Mr Anderson.

“I believe that if an independent expert were to look at the number of As relative to the number of Bs and the inherent risk in the Bs, they would create a more favourable ratio for the As. The Bs are supposed to be the riskier investment also, which receives more volatile returns and the ratio should represent that fact.”

Steyn Capital Management founder Andre Steyn said the share swap deal did not take into account that A unitholders had invested in the specific units because they wanted a lower risk investment. “Suddenly changing the rights of shares which were meant as low-risk, debt-like instruments into more risky equity-like shares is akin to walking into a French restaurant only to be handed a Chinese menu.”

Grindrod owns more than 5% of Hospitality’s A shares while Steyn owns about 1.84%. But the deal is likely to go ahead at the current share swap ratio, according to Brendon Hubbard, a fund manager at ClucasGray, and a B unitholder.

“I have been part of a team of B shareholders which has met regularly with the A share holders and Hospitality.

“We believe we have come to an agreement which will be accepted, the dual structure will end and Tsogo will come in and turn this company around.”

Hospitality management could not be reached for comment at the time of going to press.

source Business Day

Last modified on Sunday, 13 December 2015 15:24

Most Popular

Balwin's Munyaka registers record R850 million in opening weekend sales, selling 555 apartments

Mar 09, 2020
JSE listed Balwin Properties, a developer that cares about environmentally responsible…

Balwin Properties and ABSA launch South Africa’s first green home loan

Mar 13, 2020
Apartment 71933
JSE-listed Balwin Properties Limited (Balwin Properties or the Company) and Absa Group…

Growthpoint reports a steady first half with its growth strategies paying dividends

Mar 11, 2020
Growthpoint Properties Group CEO Norbert Sassee
Growthpoint Properties (JSE: GRT) reported distributable income growth of 2.2% to R3.2bn,…

Spear REIT launches innovative self-isolation campaign for returning travellers in Cape Town, South Africa to combat COVID-19:

Mar 18, 2020
Double Tree Op
JSE listed Spear REIT Limited, the owner of the Double Tree by Hilton Cape Town, is the…

Financial Fitness – Is this the right time to buy property?

Mar 20, 2020
Governor Lesetja Kganyago SARB1
With the South African Reserve Bank’s announcement of interest rates cut of 100 basis…

Please publish modules in offcanvas position.